Excessive nitrogen (N) uptake for nutrient use in food production and industry and increased N losses to the environment severely interfere with nutrient cycles and harm the environment and thus, closing N cycles through N recovery and recycling is required to improve N use efficiency. To quantify positive impacts enhancing N cycles, this study suggests a novel N handprint approach, which combines life cycle assessment based nutrient footprint and carbon handprint approaches. The N handprint comprises of a set of indicators providing a wide systemic view on changes in N cycles. The case study demonstrates that the N handprint is created when a recycled N nutrient product is used instead of a virgin N nutrient for the needs of a pulp and paper mill wastewater treatment. According to our results, the handprint equals a reduction of 454 kg of virgin N inputs, and 5.6 kg of total N inputs for daily treated wastewater. Additionally, global warming potential is 91%, and the eutrophication potential 48% lower for the recycled N nutrient than for the virgin N nutrient. These results can be used to promote the use of recycled N on similar occasions in order to improve nutrient use efficiency.